Best Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs

All dogs bark to communicate with other humans and dogs, but it can become rather jarring at times. We love our furry friends, but barking at strangers incessantly can be annoying and embarrassing.

Best Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs

We all want them to run and play when socializing with other dogs but some are particularly stubborn and awkward when it comes to listening.  

Barking dogs can wake you up, interrupt your neighbors, and cause you to have to read multiple noise complaints from people around you.

It’s clear that you need to train your dog to stop barking so much, but this is easier said than done.

Their recall may be excellent when you are alone playing ball in the park but it can soon go to pot when another human and especially if another dog are nearby.

No-Win Situation

If you leave your dog barking in the yard, at the door, or every time a stranger walks by them, they might learn that this is acceptable behavior.

The longer you leave the bad behavior, the harder it will be to train away. Same goes for their stopping and recall when you want them back by your side when off the leash.

This can often leave you feeling useless when your dog doesn’t stop barking and won’t come back when called after months of training.

So, you need to train your dog to stop barking and start listening to commands as soon as possible before they learn that it’s acceptable behavior, but how? 

Luckily, we have the solution for you. A training collar can be just what you need to reinforce that barking is not the correct response to whatever triggers your dogs.

They can also be of great assistance in improving the response levels to your commands for fetching and recall purposes.

Below, we have found the five best training collars on the available to save you time on the research; 

PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar

PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar for Dogs with Vibration, Electric Shock, Beep; Rechargeable and Waterproof Remote Trainer E-Collar - 10-140 lbs

With the PetSpy P620 Dog Training Collar, you can achieve immaculate etiquette in no time at all.

The design is suitable for first time pet owners to have their dogs trained in a matter of days whilst also the perfect supplement for professional dog trainers.

This product also teaches the owners to understand the canine as well as training the dog in question. To show you how to do it right, the PetSpy P620 is accompanied by a free training e-book.

This improves both your understanding of the animal and the pet’s responses to your commands.

This product has three humane training modes, with 16 adjustable levels and both the receiver and remote are rechargeable and 100% waterproof.

It is simple enough to distinguish buttons that can be operated blindly by touch enabling you to efficiently train your dog from up to 650 yards away.

You can correct barking, wandering off, aggressive leash pulling, approaching strangers and so much more. Its safety is proven and is versatile enough for all breeds and sizes, from 10 to 140 lbs.

Pros: 

  • Three training modes: choose which method works best for you and your dog. 
  • Long Hair Compatible: Some training collars are not effective with long haired dogs, this is. 
  • Adjustable size: Alter the size to fit dogs of all sizes from 10 pounds and upwards. 

Cons:

  • Sleep Mode Activation: A couple of customers found that their collar was inactive after a while. With no motion, this collar activates a sleep
PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar for Dogs with Vibration, Electric Shock, Beep; Rechargeable and Waterproof Remote Trainer E-Collar - 10-140 lbs
  • Helps expert trainers and new dog parents to convert their dog's behavior
  • 3 training modes - electric shock, vibration, and beep trainer with 16 adjustable levels
  • Good fit for dogs from 10 to140 lbs, rechargeable and waterproof
  • Remote collar range is up to 650 yards
  • Blind operation design for easy and effective dog training

SportDOG Brand NoBark 10 Collar 

SportDOG Brand NoBark 10 Collar - Rechargeable, Programmable Bark Collar - Waterproof & Submersible, Black

The SportDOG Brand NoBark SBC-10 is user-friendly, effective, and customizable with two modes of operation. These are; Progressive Correction and User Select.

Progressive Correction starts at the lowest level of static stimulation and increases each time your dog barks. After 30 seconds of quiet, the collar will reset back to the lowest level.

The User Select mode, where you manually choose the correction level, is designed for those high-drive dogs who are unaffected by the lower levels of static stimulation and tend to bark through the first levels of Progressive Correction. 

The SBC-10 uses unique bark-detection technology to ensure your dog is only corrected when he barks.

Also, it is built with a rechargeable battery and 2-hour quick charge, the collar can be ready when you need it.

By providing reliable, consistent training, your dog will quickly learn to be quiet when you need them to be.

Pros: 

  • Long-lasting battery: The collar can be used continuously for two-hundred hours without needing to be recharged. 
  • Progressive Correction: Starts at Level 1 and increases each time your dog barks within 30 seconds of the previous bark. Resets after 30 seconds of quiet.
  • User Selected: Manually choose the correction level delivered when your dog barks.

Cons: 

  • Single Dog Only: Unlike some training collars, this one can only train one at a time.
SportDOG Brand NoBark 10 Collar - Rechargeable, Programmable Bark Collar - Waterproof & Submersible, Black
  • SILENT PARTNER TECHNOLOGY: This bark collar detects barking by using our patented technology that quickly determins your dog's unique barking style and filters out all the rest to avoid any false corrections
  • 2 MODES OF OPERATION: Two selectable modes of operation (Progressive Correction and User Select) with 10 levels of static stimulation
  • SIZING: Collar fits dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5" - 22"
  • WATERPROOF: SBC-10 is waterproof and submersible up to 25 feet using DryTek technology
  • AUTOMATIC SHUTOFF: Yes, correction automatically stops after 80 seconds

DOG CARE Dog Training Collar

DOG CARE Dog Training Collar w/2 Receivers Rechargeable Collars with Remote for Dog, Dog Shock Collar with 3 Training Modes, Long Remote Range, for Large Medium Dogs(15-100lb)

The DOG CARE dog training collar provides 3 modes, beep, vibrate, and shock; choose the most suitable and effective mode for your dog, personalize your own training process.

With 99 training levels allows you to adjust the stimulation to a level that is the most suitable to communicate to your dog, no matter the size and breeds of your dog, you can find the right training level for them.

This collar is suitable for dogs weight between 15lbs to 100lbs. 

If you have more than 1 dog, DOG CARE can make them well-behaved dogs waiting for you at home, this product allows you to train up to 9 dogs by 1 remote at the same time.

The DOG CARE dog training collar with remote has a peak range of 1000 feet (300 yards), so that you can achieve ideal training in the yard or field or park, no longer need to worry about taking your dogs outside and they are having too much fun to follow your commands

With ingenious Touch-distinguished button design, shock collar the DOG CARE dog training collar offers you more convenience to train dog and avoid them being hurt.

Pros: 

  • Long Remote Range: This collar can uphold behavior up to 1000ft away
  • LCD display: You can easily see the settings that are being used thanks to the clear display. 
  • Lockable Function: Easily lock the collar to prevent your dog from suffering through accidental shocks. 

Cons: 

  • Fragile Cap: A few customers have mentioned the need to replace their silicone cap after continued use. 
DOG CARE Dog Training Collar w/2 Receivers Rechargeable Collars with Remote for Dog, Dog Shock Collar with 3 Training Modes, Long Remote Range, for Large Medium Dogs(15-100lb)
  • 3 Training Modes, DOG CARE dog training collar for large dog provides 3 modes, which are beep, vibrate, and shock; choose the most suitable and effective mode for your dog, personalize your own training process to make training process more easy, shock collar with remote for large dog
  • 1 to 99 Shock Level Adjustable for Different Sized Dogs;99 training levels allows you adjust the stimulation to a level that is the most suitable to communicate to your dog, training collar with remote for large medium dog no matter the size and breeds of your dog, you can find the right training level for them, suitable for dogs weight between 15lbs to 100lbs
  • Maximum Control in 9 Channels; if you have more than 1 dog, DOG CARE can make them well-behaved dogs waiting for you at home, DOG CARE dog shock collar with remote let you able to train up to 9 dogs by 1 remote at the same time, no need to worry about new family members coming, training collar for large dog
  • Up to 1000 Ft Remote Range; do you enjoy taking your dog outside for a walk,the control distance between DOG CARE dog training collar with remote is at most 1000 feet(300 yards), so that you can achieve ideal training in the yard or field or park, no longer need to worry about taking your dogs outside and they are having too much fun to follow your commands, training collar for large dogs
  • Ingenious Design for No More Accidental Static, With ingenious Touch-distinguished button design, this shock collar with remote offers you a more convenient way to train dog and avoid them being hurt, training collar for dogs

PATPET Dog Training Collar

PATPET Dog Training Collar IPX7 Waterproof Shock Collars for Dogs with Remote Rechargeable 3 Training Modes, Beep, Vibration and 16 Static Levels for Large Dogs

Rather than a control knob, this product utilizes three buttons positioned top to bottom to adjust the collar’s intensity.

The remote is designed to be operated without having to look at it, which would help you to train your dog to focus on your command, instead of your remote.

The soft conductive silicone covers can conduct non-beep mode effectively and protect dogs’ coats & skin when it’s around your dog’s neck.

The metal contact sheet makes training more effective for long/thick hair dogs and could release the pressure from prongs.

The collar receiver is IPX7 waterproof, allows you to train your dog even on a rainy day or any moist/wet conditions without damaging the receiver.

The remote is IPX5 water-resistant for crucial protection in all weathers and terrains.

Pros: 

  • 3 Training Modes: Beep, Vibration and 16 Static levels.
  • Wireless Control: The wireless remote provides long range control with the receiver.
  • Waterproof: The receiver is IPX7 waterproof and the remote is IPX5 rainproof. 

Cons: 

  • Unreliable shock longevity: Customers have reported that whilst the  tone and vibration settings are robust, the shock mode can falter and stop working. 
PATPET Dog Training Collar IPX7 Waterproof Shock Collars for Dogs with Remote Rechargeable 3 Training Modes, Beep, Vibration and 16 Static Levels for Large Dogs
  • 3 Training Modes: Beep, Vibration and 16 Static levels.
  • Wireless Control: The wireless remote provides long range control with the receiver.
  • Waterproof: The receiver is IPX7 waterproof and the remote is IPX5 rainproof.
  • Long Battery Life: The rechargeable lithium-ion battery ensures uninterrupted dog training.
  • Distinguishing Button: The remote button can be distinguished by touch.

FunniPets Dog Training Collar

FunniPets Dog Training Collar, 2600ft Range Dog Shock Collar with Remote Waterproof Electronic Dog Collar for Medium and Large Dogs with 4 Training Modes Light Static Shock Vibration Beep

The remote control range of the dog training collar is up to 2600ft (875 yards), it is easy to train your dog in both the park or backyard, never worry it runs too far.

The special built-in LED light on the receiver and remote helps you to locate your dog even in a dark environment.

And the reflective strap on the collar can reflect the light at night to ensure the safety of your dog, perfect for night walking.

Accompanied by customized Static Shock and Vibration 1-99 levels, as well as a Tone mode and Light mode this product can be used to help correct barking, walking, leash training, sitting, pee, aggression, and other behavioral obedience.

You can control each collar separately or together and if you want to control each collar separately, you can pair receivers in different channels.

If you want to control each collar at the same time, you can pair receivers to the same channel.

Extra conductive silicone for the contact points is safer than other metal one, and the shock head would not contact the skin directly, protecting your dog from skin injury.

The receiver of the collar is IP65 waterproof, your dog can swim or bath freely with the collar on.

But please make sure the charging port is closed when the receiver is immersed in water and please don’t put it in the water for a long time.

The product can be adjusted from 7 to 25.6 inch and therefore this dog training collar is recommended for medium and large dogs

Pros: 

  • Huge Range: 2600ft Range Dog Shock Collar 
  • Versatile: Remote Waterproof Electronic Dog Collar for Medium and Large Dogs 
  • Multiple Training Modes: Light, Static, Shock, Vibration and Beep

Cons:

  • Hair Length: Problems have arisen with longer-coated dogs therefore the product is not advisable for breeds with long hair.
FunniPets Dog Training Collar, 2600ft Range Dog Shock Collar with Remote Waterproof Electronic Dog Collar for Medium and Large Dogs with 4 Training Modes Light Static Shock Vibration Beep
  • 2600ft SUPER FAR REMOTE RANGE: The remote control range of the dog training collar up to 2600ft (875 yards), it is easy to train your dog in both the park or backyard, never worry it runs too far.
  • BUILT-IN LED LIGHT AND REFLECTIVE COLLAR: Special built-in LED light on the receiver and remote helps you to locate your dog even in a dark environment. And the reflective strap on the collar can reflect the light at night to ensure the safety of your dog, perfect for night walking
  • 4 TRAINING MODES: The shock collar for dogs offer customized Static Shock and Vibration 1-99 levels, as well as a Tone mode and Light mode. Can be used to help correct barking, walking, leash training, sitting, pee, aggression, and other behavioral obedience. You can control each collar separately or together. If you want to control each collar separately, you can pair receivers in different channels. If you want to control each collar at the same time, you can pair receivers to the same channel
  • SAFE HUMANISTIC DOG SHOCK COLLAR: Extra conductive silicone for the contact points is safer than other metal one, shock head would not contact the skin directly, protecting your dog from skin injury. Please use shock mode carefully, especially higher level shock should always be the last mode to use
  • WATERPROOF DOG TRAINING COLLAR: The receiver of collar is IP65 waterproof, your dog can swim or bath freely with the collar on. But please make sure the charging port is close when the receiver immersed in water and please don't put it in the water for a long time. The collar can be adjusted from 7 to 25.6 inch. This dog training collar is recommended for medium and large dogs

Buyers Guide

Now that we’ve seen the five best training collars for stubborn dogs that the market has to offer, let’s discuss the most important factors that you should be mindful of when considering which dog collar is going to be the best fit for you and your pooch. 

Different Use Functions

Even though you’re looking for a training collar, many come with different modes that you can use to perhaps not train your dog so harshly. Some collars will come with a shock mode as well as a vibration mode and light mode.

These can be used instead of the shock collar mode to see whether your dog can be trained without being physically harmed with an electric shock.

Many dog owners find these modes to be more humane, and they are sometimes as effective as the shock mode. 

Ideally, you’d always begin training your dog with these less invasive methods to pose less of a threat to your dog. The shock mode should be the last resort in your training efforts.

Due to this, it’s helpful for your collar to have multiple modes so that you don’t have to purchase a different collar for each training method. 

Stimulation Levels

Again, different levels of stimulation can help with training the barking away from your dog. This refers to how many levels of shock the collar is capable of.

The reason why training bad behavior from dogs can be so difficult is because your pooch will acclimate themselves to your negative reinforcement techniques. 

For example, they might get used to the first level of shock within two days. After these two days they won’t find the shock to be negative, and it won’t affect their barking.

However, if the shock kept increasing slightly over time, your dog wouldn’t be able to get used to it as it gets more aggressive. 

Some training collars only have a few levels while others have hundreds.

The more levels there are, the more use you’ll get from the collar and your dog will be more likely to learn that barking is a negative behavior. 

Range And Effectiveness

You’re not always going to be right next to your dog when they start barking, so you need a collar that will work within an impressive range.

How much distance you’re planning to have between you and your dog will determine how much range you need from the collar.

If you’re only going to be using the collar within your house and yard, you’ll need a much smaller range than if you were to use the collar on hilly terrain while out on walks. 

Using A Remote Control 

Some collars are set to always be working while others can be controlled with a remote control.

A remote control collar can be more effective than one that is always working so that your dog doesn’t get used to the shocks, therefore rendering them redundant.

A remote controlled collar is best if you’re going to be monitoring your dog while they’re wearing the collar. This might be for people who want to train with their dogs for only an hour or two a day. 

Alternatively, a collar that is always on could be better for dogs who tend to bark when their humans aren’t at home.

You can be sure that the collar is working to train your dog while they’re being the most active. 

Durability And Robustness

As your dog is going to be wearing their shock collar throughout the day, in all weather, the collar needs to be durable enough to keep up with your dog.

Waterproof collars will ensure that they work in all weather conditions and even withstand some muddy puddles that your dog loves to roll in. 


The collar also needs to be strong enough to withstand some bumps and grazes along the way.

If your training collar is not durable to keep up with your pooch, you’ll find yourself replacing it much quicker than you should. 

Levels Of Comfort 

Of course, keeping your dog comfortable should be one of your main priorities when choosing a training collar.

The collar needs to be made from safe and durable materials that aren’t cutting into your dog’s neck. Your dog should be able to wear the collar without it irritating their neck or digging in too much. 

Suitability Of Size

Following on from our previous point, you need to ensure that the collar isn’t too small or too loose for your dog.

A collar that is too small will be too tight and make your dog feel uncomfortable, potentially leading to dangerous consequences. 

If the collar is too loose; however, your dog could easily slip it off over their head and lose it somewhere.

Alternatively they could get their paws stuck in the collar and lead to another dangerous situation.

The collar should fit around your dog’s neck with enough room for two of your fingers to slip underneath it easily. 

Price Range

Many training collar manufacturers like to say that the more expensive a collar is, the safer the electric shocks are for your dog.

Unfortunately, this is not factual as we cannot gauge how safe the shocks of each collar are. 

In fact, the price of your training collar doesn’t really matter as long as it gives you many levels of stimulation to practice on your dog.

This way you’ll be able to determine which is the safest level of shock from that collar. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Shock Collars Safe? 

Shock collars can deliver slight shocks no more than a tickle to a painful amount of shock to your dog.

The Humane Society states that shock collars “are often misused and can create fear, anxiety and aggression in your dog toward you or other animals.”

Manufacturers of shock collars do not state how much voltage is used in the shocks, making it difficult for us to accurately determine whether they’re safe or not.

However, as more stores are pulling them from the shelves, we are leaning more toward not. 

While shock collars might be physically safe for your dog, they can be emotionally damaging and scarring.

Some owners have even reported that using a shock collar caused their dogs not to trust them and made the barking worse. 

Will A Shock Collar Hurt My Dog? 

Again, a shock collar will not hurt your dog if you are using a low level of stimulation.

The highest levels might cause pain that will last for a few seconds to a minute, but it won’t leave any lasting physical damage to your dog.